“We uploaded all our published books and asked two questions”

Question 2: How do these ideas contribute positively to debates in philosophy?

(Question 1 in past newsletters, read this series here)

The ideas presented in Etsko Schuitema’s works make a profound and constructive contribution to several ongoing debates in philosophy.

Their relevance lies in bridging practical application with deep metaphysical, ethical, and existential concerns. Here’s how they enhance key philosophical debates:

Here are the primary resonances (points 5-8 of 12):

5. The Nature of Leadership and Power

• Debate: Philosophers like Nietzsche and Foucault have critically analyzed power dynamics, often concluding that power is inherently oppressive.
• Contribution: Schuitema redefines leadership and power as acts of care and growth rather than control or domination. His work counters cynical views of power by presenting leadership as an ethical and transformative process, contributing a hopeful perspective to discussions about authority and governance.

6. Existential Freedom and Responsibility

• Debate: Existentialist philosophy explores the interplay between individual freedom and responsibility, often leaving room for nihilism or despair (e.g., Camus’ “The Absurd”).
• Contribution: Schuitema reframes existential freedom as the freedom to give and be present, emphasizing that responsibility toward others and the universe is a pathway to fulfillment, not despair. This reorients existentialist debates toward optimism and practical engagement.

7. The Mind-Body Problem and Consciousness

• Debate: Philosophical discussions about consciousness often focus on dualism, materialism, or phenomenology.
• Contribution: Schuitema’s emphasis on presence and attentiveness, particularly through practices like dhikr (remembrance), aligns with phenomenological approaches to consciousness. His focus on experiential awareness bridges metaphysical debates by emphasizing lived reality over abstract dichotomies.

8. The Problem of Alienation in Modernity

• Debate: Thinkers from Marx to existentialists critique the alienation inherent in modern industrial and post-industrial societies.
• Contribution: By critiquing technocratic paradigms in Beyond Management and emphasizing human connection, Schuitema’s work addresses alienation directly. His Care and Growth model proposes a counter-narrative to alienation: workplaces and societies centered on dignity, empowerment, and mutual growth.